Can You Make Sandwiches The Night Before? (6 Tips)

Hey there! Some links on this page are affiliate links, which means I may receive a small commission, at no cost to you, if you make a purchase through a link. I greatly appreciate your support!

Sandwiches are one of the best choices for breakfast, lunches and tea parties. 

They are easy to prepare, delicious, and very filling too. 

But when you have a packed routine, you might not have time to cook and build the sandwiches. 

This is where advanced meal preparation comes in to makes things easier and manageable.

But, can you actually make sandwiches the night before without the bread getting soggy?

Let’s find out! 

You can make a sandwiches the night before for breakfast, lunch or if you are having a tea party in the afternoon. However, there are a few crucial tips and tricks to follow in order to make the freshest, perfect sandwich that will satisfy your appetite and not get soggy.

In this article we’ll provide you with everything you need to know to prepare the most perfect sandwiches. 

We’ll also provide you with some easy make-ahead sandwiches ideas that you will definitely enjoy.

So why wait? Let us open up the secrets to these sandwiches and make your life easier and more delicious!

Tips For Making Sandwiches Ahead Of Time

Now, let’s start off with some crucial tips that will change your sloppy sandwich into a decent one. 

These tips will undoubtedly make the make-ahead sandwich as fresh as they are just made.

Choice Of Bread

Bread is like the foundation of the sandwich, so it is essential to have the best bread. 

Make sure to choose wisely between the types of bread that are available. 

We recommend firm pieces of bread over softer (milk) breads because the soft ones will get soggy from the filling. 

For example, a firmer bread, like sourdough or rye, will hold up better overnight than a softer bread, like challah or brioche.

Another great tip that always works for us is toasting the bread

Even though the bread will not remain crispy and toasted by the time you eat, it will prevent it from getting soggy and soft.

Choice Of Cheese

For make-ahead sandwiches, we suggest using sturdy cheeses like Swiss, cheddar, or provolone instead of fresh mozzarella and goat cheese. 

Soft cheeses tend to make your sandwich soggy quicker than you think, so it is crucial to have a reliable, low-moisture cheese.

Dry The Vegetables 

Vegetables like tomatoes, onion, lettuce, and pickles are delicious in sandwiches. 

But there are a few crucial steps we’d recommend you to follow before building your sandwich the night before:

  • Dry all leafy vegetables, especially the lettuce, before building the sandwich. You can use a salad spinner or pat them dry with a kitchen towel.
  • If you want pickles and tomatoes in your sandwich, pat them dry. Draw out as much water as you can.

Don’t Overload Your Sandwiches

Another crucial tip to make your sandwiches hold up well is to avoid overloading them.

Too much filling will make your sandwich soggy. 

Store Your Sandwiches In The Fridge

Storing your sandwiches properly will help tremendously when it comes to keeping them fresh overnight. 

I personally like to use airtight containers, but you can also use resealable plastic bags.

Make sure to remove as much air from the bag as possible before sealing it shut.

If you’re using a container, make sure to put a paper towel at the bottom before placing your sandwiches inside. 

This will help absorb any moisture that may escape overnight.

Hack For Creamy Fillings

Pack your creamy fillings and the bread separately for creamy salad sandwiches like tuna and egg sandwiches. 

This will help you to have all ingredients with you; just assemble and eat the sandwich for lunch.

Easy Make-Ahead Sandwiches

To give you some tasty ideas for easy make-ahead sandwiches, here are our top 5 favorites sandwich styles that will hold up well and stay fresh and soggy-free:

Grilled Veggie Sandwich

All you need for this sandwich is tomato, avocado, portobello mushrooms, and mayo (or hummus if you want to make it vegan)

Just grill slices of tomatoes and mushrooms and assemble your sandwich. 

It is flavorful and perfect.

Egg Salad Sandwich

Just boil some eggs, peel them, and chop them. 

Add mayonnaise, a little cream, salt pepper, and if you feel extra fancy, you can shredded cheddar cheese and paprika. 

Mix it up, and store it in small airtight containers along with your bread. 

Pack them up for the next day, and you are good to go. 

This is super fun for kids as well since it gives them the freedom to create their own sandwiches.

Club sandwich

A club sandwich is a classic, and we all love it. 

All you need is some chicken (or a vegetarian/vegan substitute), shredded cheese and vegetables of your choice; we love to use lettuce and tomato.

Add mayonnaise, salt, pepper, and paprika for an extra spicy kick. 

Store the filling in the airtight container with some bread, and you are ready.

Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich

This childhood classic is always a hit! 

For an easy meal prep, make a big batch of peanut butter and jelly sandwiches at the beginning of the week. 

Make sure to spread peanutbutter on both sides of the sandwich before adding jelly to prevent the bread from getting soggy.

Then, store them in the fridge and enjoy one whenever you’re craving a PB&J!

Pinwheel Sandwiches

All you need for these awesome pinwheel sandwiches is some tortillas or flattened bread.

Spread some mayonnaise, add your favorite ingredients like some cheese or vegetables.

Sprinkle some salt and pepper if you like to spice it up. 

Roll the bread, cut it into pieces, and pack it up. 

It is easy and fun to make with the kids, especially on Sunday night for the Monday lunch.

Other Questions You May Have

Is It Safe To Make Sandwiches Ahead Of Time?

It is generally safe to make sandwiches ahead of time. However, there are a few things to keep in mind.

If you are using perishable ingredients like meat, cheese, or eggs, it’s important to store the sandwiches in the refrigerator.

It’s also important to make sure that the sandwiches are wrapped tightly. This will help keep them fresh!

How Long Can You Keep Sandwiches In The Fridge?

If you store sandwiches in the fridge, they will generally stay good to eat for about 3 days (as long as all the ingredients are fresh)

After that, the quality of the sandwich will start to decline. 

Can You Freeze Sandwiches?

You can definitely freeze sandwiches! 

Just make sure to wrap them tightly in plastic wrap or aluminum foil. 

Frozen sandwiches will be good for around 2 months.

Can You Make Cucumber Sandwiches The Night Before?

Cucumber sandwiches are not the greatest make-ahead option, as cucumbers tend to release a lot of water overnight. 

This can make the bread soggy

If you insist on making cucumber sandwiches ahead of time, consider using a thick bread like pumpernickel, and be sure to drain the cucumbers well before adding them to the sandwich. 

You can also add the cucumber the next morning, just before eating. 

Can You Make Tea Sandwiches The Night Before? 

Tea sandwiches are great to make ahead of time! 

Just be sure to use a crustless bread, as the crusts will become hard overnight.

If you want to avoid the bread becoming soggy, you can toast the bread before assembling the sandwich. 

You can also add ingredients such as cucumber or tomato just before eating, as they will not release as much water that way.

Can You Make Finger Sandwiches Ahead Of Time? 

​​You can certainly make finger sandwiches ahead of time. 

In fact, it is often easier to do so, as you can avoid the rush of last-minute sandwich making. 

Simply make the sandwiches as you would normally, then wrap them tightly in plastic wrap or aluminum foil. 

If you will be storing them for more than a few hours, you may also want to place them in a covered container or resealable bag. 

When you are ready to serve the sandwiches, simply unwrap and enjoy.

If you have made them ahead of time, you may also want to consider heating them up slightly before serving, as this can help to re-crisp the bread and make them even more enjoyable.

What Are Some Good Cheese Sandwich Fillings?

In addition to the classic grilled cheese, try layering different types of sliced, shredded or spreadable cheeses like cheddar, Swiss, provolone or cream cheese. Other tasty additions include sliced tomato, alfalfa or watercress sprouts, thinly sliced apple or pear. 

For best results, consider using a cookie cutter next time to cut the cheese sandwiches into small sandwiches and fun shapes for lunch boxes.

How Can I Prevent The Bread From Drying Out Overnight?

In addition to tightly wrapping each sandwich, place a damp paper towel in the airtight container when storing overnight. The towel will add just enough moisture to prevent drying without resulting in soggy bread. 

You can also store sandwiches in the fridge in single layers separated by a baking sheet or wax paper for airflow. That way you’ll be able to enjoy the best bread at lunch time!

Can I Make Open-Faced Sandwiched To Take For Afternoon Tea?

Open-faced sandwiches are a great option for afternoon tea. Meal prep sandwiches on split english muffins or slices of a sturdy type of bread like sourdough bread spread with cream cheese. Top with sliced cucumbers, watercress, salmon mousse or chicken salad.

Wrap tightly in parchment paper to take along.

What Kinds Of Fillings Work For Children’s School Lunch Box?

Some kid-friendly make-ahead sandwich fillings for their school lunches include peanut or almond butter with banana slices, cream cheese mixed with jam, sliced hard boiled eggs, fried egg, chicken or tuna salad, and ham or turkey with a slice of cheese.

Final Thoughts

Sandwiches are one of the most versatile food choices for lunch. 

They are easy to make, fulfilling and can be made with anything you want. 

So why not have a recipe that you can make ahead of time and have tension-free mornings without any fuzz.

In this article, we have disclosed some fantastic tips to make a perfect sandwich that stays fresh till your lunch. 

We have also included our favorite recipes for some sandwich inspiration! Enjoy!

Recent Posts